Question
HLPaper 1
1.[15]
Using real-world examples, evaluate transfer payments as a measure to reduce poverty.
Verified
Solution
Answers may include:
Definitions
- Transfer Payments: Transfer payments are redistributions of income by the government to individuals or households without any exchange of goods or services.
- Poverty: The inability to meet standard consumption needs. These standards can be absolute or relative.
- Redistribution of Income: A policy intended to adjust the distribution of wealth by transferring income from wealthier to poorer individuals.
Economic Theory
-
Purpose of Transfer Payments:
- Transfer payments aim to provide financial support to low-income individuals, thereby increasing their disposable income.
- By increasing disposable income, transfer payments can help individuals meet basic needs, reducing absolute poverty.
-
Mechanism:
- Transfer payments are funded through taxation, primarily from higher-income groups, and redistributed to lower-income groups.
- This redistribution can lead to a more equitable income distribution, potentially reducing income inequality.
-
Impact on Aggregate Demand:
- Increased disposable income for low-income individuals can lead to higher consumption, as these individuals have a higher marginal propensity to consume.
- This increase in consumption can boost aggregate demand, potentially leading to economic growth and job creation.
-
Diagram:
- Lorenz Curve: Illustrates income distribution. Transfer payments can shift the Lorenz Curve closer to the line of equality, indicating a more equitable distribution of income.
- Lorenz Curve: Illustrates income distribution. Transfer payments can shift the Lorenz Curve closer to the line of equality, indicating a more equitable distribution of income.
Evaluation (SLAP)
-
Stakeholders:
- Beneficiaries: Low-income individuals benefit directly from increased financial support.
- Taxpayers: Higher-income individuals may face higher taxes to fund transfer payments, potentially reducing their disposable income.
- Government: Must balance fiscal sustainability with social welfare objectives.
-
Long-run vs. Short-run:
- Short-run: Immediate reduction in poverty levels as individuals receive financial support.
- Long-run: Potential dependency on government support if not coupled with policies promoting self-sufficiency, such as education and job training.
-
Advantages vs. Disadvantages:
- Advantages: Directly reduces poverty, improves living standards, and can stimulate economic activity through increased consumption.
- Disadvantages: May lead to fiscal strain if not managed properly, potential disincentive to work if benefits are too generous, and possible inefficiencies in targeting the truly needy.
-
Prioritize:
- Effective targeting and efficient administration are crucial to ensure that transfer payments reach those in need without creating significant fiscal burdens.
- Complementary policies, such as education and job training, are essential to ensure long-term poverty reduction and economic self-sufficiency.
-
Real-World Example:
- United States Supplemental Nutrition Assistance Program (SNAP):
- Provides food-purchasing assistance to low-income individuals.
- In 2020, SNAP helped lift approximately 3.2 million people out of poverty.
- However, concerns about dependency and fiscal sustainability persist.
- United States Supplemental Nutrition Assistance Program (SNAP):
Conclusion
- Transfer payments can effectively reduce poverty in the short term by increasing disposable income for low-income individuals.
- Long-term success requires complementary policies that promote economic self-sufficiency.
- Effective targeting and fiscal management are essential to maximize benefits and minimize drawbacks.
2.[10]
Explain the difficulties that exist in measuring unemployment.
Verified
Solution
Answers may include:
Definitions
- Unemployment Rate: The number of unemployed people expressed as a percentage of the labor force.
- Labor Force: The total number of people who are employed and unemployed but actively seeking work.
- Discouraged Workers: Individuals who have stopped looking for work because they believe no jobs are available for them.
Diagram
- Labor Market Diagram: While a diagram is not strictly necessary for this question, a simple labor market diagram can be used to illustrate the concept of unemployment. It should indicate the equilibrium where labor supply meets labor demand, and the gap representing unemployment.
Explanation
-
Understanding Unemployment Measurement:
- The unemployment rate is a key indicator of economic health, but it has limitations in accurately reflecting the true state of unemployment.
-
Challenges in Measuring Unemployment:
- Exclusion of Discouraged Workers:
- Discouraged workers are not counted in the unemployment rate because they are not actively seeking employment.
- This exclusion can lead to an underestimation of the true unemployment rate.
- Underemployment:
- Individuals working part-time or in jobs that do not utilize their skills are considered employed, even if they seek full-time work.
- This can mask the extent of labor underutilization in the economy.
- Informal Economy:
- Workers in the informal sector may not be captured in official statistics, leading to inaccuracies.
- This is particularly relevant in developing countries where informal employment is prevalent.
- Survey Limitations:
- Unemployment data is often collected through surveys, which can be subject to sampling errors and biases.
- Respondents may misreport their employment status, either intentionally or unintentionally.
- Exclusion of Discouraged Workers:
-
Additional Explanation:
- Structural Changes:
- Changes in the economy, such as technological advancements, can lead to structural unemployment, which may not be immediately reflected in unemployment statistics.
- This can result in a lag in data accuracy as the labor market adjusts to new conditions.
- Structural Changes:
-
Conclusion:
- While the unemployment rate is a useful economic indicator, it is important to consider its limitations and the broader context of labor market conditions.
- Policymakers should use a combination of indicators to gain a comprehensive understanding of employment dynamics.