Question
SLPaper 1
1.[10]
Using a production possibilities curve (PPC) diagram, explain how the concept of scarcity necessitates choices in all economies.
Verified
Solution
Answers may include:
Definitions
- Scarcity: The idea that available resources (land, labour, capital, entrepreneurship) are limited and unable to satisfy unlimited human needs and wants.
- Production Possibilities Curve (PPC): Curve that illustrates all possible combinations of two goods that an economy can produce at maximum output when using all available resources and current technology efficiently.
- Opportunity Cost: The value of the next best option that must be forgone or sacrificed in order to acquire something else.
Diagram
- Production Possibilities Curve (PPC) Diagram:
- The diagram should be a concave curve to the origin, illustrating the trade-offs between two goods (e.g., Good A and Good B).
- Points on the curve represent efficient production levels, points inside the curve indicate inefficient use of resources, and points outside the curve are unattainable with current resources.
- The diagram should include labeled axes, the curve itself, and at least one point inside, on, and outside the curve.
Explanation
-
Understanding Scarcity and Choices:
- Scarcity arises because resources are limited while human wants are unlimited, necessitating choices about how to allocate resources efficiently.
- The PPC illustrates scarcity by showing the limits of production capabilities given finite resources.
-
PPC and Opportunity Cost:
- Movement along the PPC demonstrates opportunity cost. Choosing more of one good results in less of another due to limited resources.
- For example, moving from one point on the PPC to another involves sacrificing some quantity of Good A to gain more of Good B, illustrating opportunity cost.
-
Efficient and Inefficient Production:
- Points on the PPC represent efficient use of resources, where the economy is maximizing its production potential.
- Points inside the curve indicate inefficiency, where resources are underutilized, possibly due to unemployment or underemployment.
-
Economic Growth and Shifts in the PPC:
- Economic growth can shift the PPC outward, indicating an increase in an economy's capacity to produce goods and services.
- This shift can result from factors such as technological advancements or an increase in resources.
2.[15]
Using real world examples, evaluate the view that a minimum wage is undesirable for an economy as a whole.
Verified
Solution
Answers may include:
Definitions
- Minimum Wage: The lowest legal remuneration that employers can pay their workers.
- Unemployment: When people of working age (16-65) who are actively seeking and able to work, but are not employed.
- Price Floor: A minimum price set by the government for a good, above the equilibrium price.
Economic Theory
-
Introduction to Minimum Wage:
- A minimum wage is set above the equilibrium wage in a competitive labour market.
- It aims to ensure a minimum standard of living for workers.
-
Effects on Labour Market:
- Price Floor: A minimum wage acts as a price floor in the labour market.
- Surplus of Labour: If set above the equilibrium wage, it can lead to a surplus of labour, i.e., unemployment, as the quantity of labour supplied exceeds the quantity demanded.
- Diagram: A standard labour market diagram should be used, showing the supply and demand for labour, with the minimum wage line above the equilibrium wage, leading to a surplus (unemployment).
-
Impact on Firms:
- Increased labour costs may lead firms to reduce hiring, cut hours, or increase prices to maintain profit margins.
- Small businesses may be disproportionately affected due to tighter budget constraints.
-
Impact on Workers:
- While some workers benefit from higher wages, others may lose jobs or face reduced hours.
- Potential for increased motivation and productivity among workers who retain their jobs.
Diagram
- Labour Market Diagram:
- X-axis: Quantity of Labour
- Y-axis: Wage Rate
- Show equilibrium wage and quantity.
- Indicate minimum wage above equilibrium, leading to a surplus (unemployment).
Evaluation (SLAP)
-
Stakeholders:
- Workers: Some benefit from higher wages, while others face unemployment.
- Firms: May experience increased costs, leading to reduced hiring or higher prices.
- Government: Balances social welfare with economic efficiency.
-
Long-run vs. Short-run:
- Short-run: Immediate unemployment effects and potential inflationary pressures.
- Long-run: Firms may adapt through automation or relocation, potentially reducing the labour force further.
-
Advantages vs. Disadvantages:
- Advantages: Reduces poverty, increases standard of living for low-income workers, and can stimulate demand through higher disposable income.
- Disadvantages: Potential for increased unemployment, especially among low-skilled workers, and higher costs for businesses.
-
Prioritize:
- The desirability of a minimum wage depends on the balance between social benefits and economic costs. Policymakers must consider local economic conditions and labour market dynamics.
- Real-world example: The federal minimum wage has been a topic of debate in the USA. Studies show mixed effects; some states with higher minimum wages have seen reduced poverty rates, while others report increased unemployment among young and low-skilled workers.
Conclusion
- The minimum wage can have both positive and negative effects on an economy, depending on various factors such as the level set and the elasticity of demand for labour.
- Real-world examples, like those from the United States, illustrate the complexity of its impact, highlighting the need for careful consideration in policy design.
- Ultimately, the desirability of a minimum wage policy is context-dependent, requiring a nuanced approach to balance economic efficiency with social equity.